Q1 2019: 1 Top-Up And Update On Plan For 2019

31 March 2019
By Maynard Paton

Happy Sunday! I hope you continue to find my Blog useful… and that your shares have rebounded following last year’s rough market.

My portfolio has advanced during the last three months — although not as much as the wider indices.

Notable price gains from Bioventix and FW Thorpe have been sadly offset by the ongoing collapse at Tasty and sluggish performances from many of my other holdings.  

The swings and roundabouts have meant that, for the first quarter, I am up only 3.9% versus a 9.5% gain enjoyed by the FTSE 100. 

Let me now explain what has happened within my portfolio during January, February and March.


Q1 share trades

I made just one share trade during Q1, a top-up of Mountview Estates. I increased my holding by 10% at £97 including all costs.

The regulated-tenancy landlord last declared a net asset value of £92 per share, although my sums suggest the firm’s balance sheet may be worth more than £200 per share. In addition, a yield of 4% seemed attractive based on historical valuations.

My review of Mountview’s half-year results contains further details of the group’s progress and my calculations.

Q1 portfolio news 

As usual I have kept an eye on all of my existing holdings — trying to spot potential buying opportunities just in case.

The Q1 developments are summarised below:

  • Confirmation of an upcoming rescue fund-raising at Tasty, and;
  • Nothing of significance from Andrews Sykes, Castings, Daejan, Mountview Estates, Oleeo and System1.

I am particularly pleased the dividend news from my portfolio has been positive. 

First-half dividends were raised 20% at Bioventix, 2% at FW Thorpe and 28% at Tristel.

Meanwhile, full-year payouts were lifted 3% at M Winkworth, 2% at Mincon and 12% at S & U.

Although City of London Investment held its first-half dividend, the company did declare a useful 13p per share special payout. 

(Shares supplying a reliable dividend income have become of greater importance to me since I recognised the drawbacks to relying on portfolio gains.)

Q1 portfolio returns

The chart below compares my portfolio’s weekly 2019 progress (in green) to that of the FTSE 100 total return index (in blue):

q1 2019 maynard paton portfolio vs ftse 100

My portfolio was neck and neck with the market until the last three weeks of March.

This next chart shows the total return (that is, the capital gain/loss plus dividends received) each holding has produced for me so far this year:

q1 2019 maynard paton portfolio share returns

Meanwhile, this chart shows each holding’s contribution towards my overall 3.9% gain:

q1 2019 maynard paton portfolio share contribution

And this chart shows my portfolio’s holdings and their weightings at the end of Q1:

q1 2019 maynard paton portfolio share weightings

Update on plan for 2019

At the start of the year I laid out a five-point plan. Let me provide an update:

1) To enjoy a market-beating — and positive — performance: Having now written a summary of all of my shares, I could be better off concentrating more on my higher-conviction positions.

My portfolio return year to date has been positive — although not market-beating so far.

I have unfortunately made no progress on concentrating more on my higher-conviction positions.

I need to identify a really outstanding opportunity before I ditch some of my existing holdings. In the meantime, I continue to scan the market through my SharePad articles.

2) To evaluate at least 20 new companies: My SharePad writing schedule ought to provide me with a good flow of fresh investment ideas.

So far this year I have studied Somero Enterprises, Plus500, Games Workshop, Apple, Hargreaves Lansdown, Accesso Technology and Craneware for SharePad.

Seven companies in three months puts me on target to surpass 20 this year. 

Of the seven shares I evaluated, Plus500 (dubious management/shady business) and Accesso Technology (acquisitive history/awkward accounts) can be quickly ignored.

I am not 100% convinced about Hargreaves Lansdown. The broker’s history and financials are terrific, but the high fees charged to customers leaves me uncomfortable. The super margins enjoyed by HL ought really to be ripe for disruption.

Somero is a difficult one. The business has developed an attractive engineering niche and I can live with the group’s lack of recurring sales. 

The difficulty lies in knowing orders could suddenly dry up if/when the North American economy falters. Nobody wants to pay a fair multiple for ‘peak’ earnings — although that has not stopped the shares from doing well during the last few years.

I am also not quite sure what to make of Somero’s hefty stock-option buybacks.

That leaves Games Workshop, Apple and Craneware — all of which appear decent businesses. 

Of the three, I prefer Games Workshop due to its sector niche and greater propensity for dividends — assuming the firm’s profit surge is not just a flash in the pan.

As US mega-caps go, Apple looks as good a bet as any, while the dilemma about Craneware remains the high valuation and how far to extrapolate the software developer’s long-term contract income.

3) To learn more about the cost of staff options: I performed a study on pension deficits last year and I plan to write a similar analysis about share options. 

Although I have started my guide to share options, the study is not yet complete. (You can read the early draft here). 

Writing the guide has forced me to learn more about options — the subject is deeper than I thought! Nonetheless, I now understand how easily investors can misinterpret the cost of options within a company’s accounts.

The rest of the guide — which will evaluate the option plans for all of my shares — will be completed later this year.

4) To see two of my 2018 losers — System1 and Tasty — recover some lost ground: Mind you, I hoped for exactly the same recovery this time last year!

Oh dear — a miracle may now be required to see Tasty recover during 2019.

True, the last results from the hapless restaurant chain indicated glimmers of trading improvements. However, what really counts is how much fresh equity will be needed to shore up the balance sheet.

Wishful thinking perhaps, but I am hopeful Tasty’s sub-£4m market cap for sales of £47m already prices in significant dilution.

My fingers are also crossed for System1. The market-research agency has yet to issue news during 2019.

5) To enhance this Blog further: I plan to i) publish follow-on articles to How Shares Helped Me Quit The Day Job; ii) showcase more charts/features from SharePad, and; iii) perhaps introduce a proper discussion forum.

I have followed up my How Shares Helped Me Quit The Day Job with The FIRE Leap: My Story To Becoming Mortgage-Free And Retiring Early.

This comprehensive write-up explains how I became mortgage-free during 2011 aged 40, and made the leap from conventional employment at the start of 2015 aged 43.

I am convinced anyone with a passion for shares and the determination to give up the 9-to-5 can take the same path.

On the forum front, I have put out a call for enthusiastic contributors. 

A handful of intrepid readers have already expressed an interest and I would welcome anybody else who wants to join a quality investment discussion forum. 

If the forum interests you, read this first then contact me here.

Finally, I have sadly made no progress with showcasing SharePad charts within my Blog. I now think that ambition will have to be left for my SharePad articles.

That is everything for this quarter. Until next time, I wish you happy and profitable investing!

Maynard Paton

PS: You can receive my blog posts through an occasional email newsletter. Click here for details.

Disclosure: Maynard owns shares in Andrews Sykes, Bioventix, Castings, City of London Investment, Daejan, Getech, Mincon, Mountview Estates, Oleeo, S&U, System1, Tasty, FW Thorpe, Tristel and M Winkworth.

6 thoughts on “Q1 2019: 1 Top-Up And Update On Plan For 2019”

  1. Thanks for your timely updates and deligently written articles. I enjoy each of them! All the best for the next 3 quarters of 2019.

  2. Thanks from me too Maynard. Always good to read your thoughts/analysis.

    I note that you like the payment of special dividends (think most of us do!) but some seem to think that when such payments are made the company is out of ideas. Any thoughts on this from your perspective. I like GAW by the way and would consider buying, along with BVXP on any market weakness. Some say a “crash” has to come sooner rather than later.

    • Hi Nick

      Thanks for the comment. Yes, I can see the ‘out of ideas’ point of view. Trouble is a lot of ideas managements come up with are expensive and do not eventually generate any worthwhile returns. I am all for boards experimenting with fledgling ideas, such as SYS1’s Ad Ratings division, but many company embark on significant acquisition strategies in particular when surplus cash has been accrued, and such strategies often do not live up to expectations. The declaration of a special dividend is reassuring, not least as it suggests management does not harbour any costly madcap ideas for the cash.



Leave a comment