[ShareScope] Screening For My Next Long-Term Winner: TATTON ASSET MANAGEMENT

***ShareScope New Subscriber Special Offer***
Readers of my blog can claim one month of free data. Click here for details.

14 December 2024
By Maynard Paton

Today I have revisited a ShareScope screen that applies two ratios favoured by ‘quality’ investors — operating margin and return on equity (ROE).

The exact criteria I re-used were:

  • An operating margin (latest and 10-year average) of 20% or more, and;
  • An ROE (latest and 10-year average) of 20% or more.

Any business with a margin and ROE of at least 20% is probably quite special.

To narrow the field down further, I also sought companies that carried net cash (i.e. net borrowings excluding IFRS 16 finance leases of less than zero):

(Source: ShareScope)

This time the filter returned 17 matches, including Rightmove, Games Workshop, Cerillion, Property Franchise and six other shares I have studied for ShareScope.

I selected Tatton Asset Management because its impressive 40%-plus margin was the highest among the remaining seven names.

Let’s take a closer look.

Read my full TATTON ASSET MANAGEMENT article for ShareScope >>

SYSTEM1: New ‘Performance Culture’ Delivers FY 2024 Platform Revenue Up 43%, Record £208k Employee Productivity And Tantalising Illustrative £18m Ebitda Projection Supporting Possible £16 Share Price

30 November 2024
By Maynard Paton

FY 2024 results summary for System1 (SYS1):

  • The positive transition to data services continues, with a new “performance culture” delivering FY platform revenue up 43%, the highest reported FY profit for seven years and a reinstated annual dividend.
  • SYS1’s “unique selling proposition of predictiveness” keeps winning ad-testing clients, plaudits and attention, but remains frustratingly under-exploited for innovation testing that offers a 5x addressable market.
  • The bumper 87% gross margin, record £208k revenue per employee and near-£10m cash position were counterbalanced by one-off profit gains, mediocre bank interest and hefty bonuses obscuring margin progress.
  • The board’s true growth ambitions will be revealed through a revised LTIP, and I would trust the award-winning directors to retain the scheme’s £45m-£88m revenue range and reinstate a profit ‘underpin’.
  • A tantalising illustrative projection of revenue doubling to £60m should be very achievable given SYS1’s “3 Reasons to Believe“, and would support an adjusted Ebitda of £18m — and possible £16 share price — if the group’s margin target is met.

Read more

[SharePad] Screening For My Next Long-Term Winner: WYNNSTAY

***ShareScope New Subscriber Special Offer***
Readers of my blog can claim one month of free data. Click here for details.

08 November 2024
By Maynard Paton

I am back again looking for ‘value bargains’ and revisiting a screen that identifies companies trading at less than book value.

Importantly, this screen attempts to avoid ‘value traps’ by demanding the shares offer net cash, dividend payments and a history of trading above book value.

The exact filter criteria I redeployed were:

  • A price to net tangible assets of no more than 1;
  • A dividend being paid during the most recent year;
  • A 10-year average price to net tangible assets of at least 1;
  • Net borrowings less total leases of no more than 0 (i.e. a net cash position excluding IFRS 16 lease obligations), and;
  • A share price denominated in pounds sterling.

This time SharePad returned 13 companies:

(Source: SharePad)

I selected Wynnstay because the shares were priced at a steep discount versus their ten-year average valuation. I also liked the reassuring 20-year run of dividend payments.

Sure enough, Wynnstay’s 318p shares trade nearly 40% below the group’s 503p per share net tangible asset value:

(Source: SharePad)

My filter results indicate the shares have traded at an average 1.2x book value during the last ten years. The rating reached 2.3x during 2013, sank to 0.5x during the pandemic and languishes now at a lowly 0.6x.

Wynnstay’s net tangible assets have advanced over time, and so has the dividend. The payout has in fact been lifted every year since the group joined AIM during 2004 at 190p:

(Source: SharePad)

Given the illustrious dividend, Wynnstay does not seem the type of business that should be valued well below asset value. Yet the shares have effectively moved sideways for years; the recent 318p price was first achieved during 2011 and today supports a £73m market cap.

Let’s take a closer look.

Read my full WYNNSTAY article for SharePad >>

Maynard Paton

MOUNTVIEW ESTATES: £90 Shares Trade 12% Below NAV — Steepest Discount For More Than 10 Years — After FY 2024 Admits Third Consecutive Sub-60% Gross Margin And Re-Emphasises Subpar Gains From Post-2014 Purchases

02 November 2024
By Maynard Paton

FY 2024 results summary for Mountview Estates (MTVW):

  • A reasonable FY performance, which showed revenue up 8%, profit up 22% and the final dividend up 10% after buyers looking for “improvement potential” paid “good prices” for a more normal “profile” of properties.
  • Sales by larger landlords allowed MTVW to spend a substantial £48m on new properties, but the advance to net asset value (NAV) was just 2% after MTVW took on greater debt, paid 6%-plus interest, incurred higher tax and sold properties for £59m.
  • The absence of another formal estate valuation remains frustrating, especially given properties purchased after a 2014 valuation continue to realise subpar ‘reversionary’ gains and the overall property-sales gross margin was less than 60% for the third consecutive year.
  • The board continues to be well paid, attract 30%-plus protest votes and enjoy entrenched support through a family concert party… although not every family member seems a die-hard shareholder and recent AGM remarks even hinted MTVW could one day undertake a trade sale.
  • The £90 shares offer a 5.8% income, trade 12% below NAV — the steepest discount for at least ten years — and may be worth £182 if the group’s properties were all sold today at their vacant possession value. I continue to hold.

Read more

BIOVENTIX: Record H1 2024 Reveals Profit Up 15% Despite Slowing Troponin Growth As Encouraging Alzheimer’s Work Attracts ‘Significant Attention’ And Research-Test Availability Through Quanterix

22 October 2024
By Maynard Paton

H1 2024 results summary for Bioventix (BVXP):

  • A record H1, showing revenue up 13%, profit up 15% and the dividend up 10% as greater sales to China helped offset a “temporary” slowing of troponin growth.
  • Positive long-term progress continues to rest upon Alzheimer’s R&D, in which a study involving pTau212 suggests BVXP may enjoy a research edge beyond an increasingly crowded pTau217 field.
  • BVXP’s Alzheimer’s work on ‘brain-derived tau’ has attracted “significant attention” for helping identify significant, near-term “cognitive decline”, and is now available through Quanterix for wider research purposes.
  • The economics of successful antibodies remain superb, with this H1 displaying a terrific 77% operating margin, net cash equivalent to a hefty 40% of revenue and capex of just £5k.
  • The £37 shares yield a trailing 4.3%, trade at a possible 22x P/E and might — using some very basic assumptions — value the R&D pipeline at £23m. I continue to hold.

Read more

[SharePad] Small-Cap Spotlight Report: SOFTWARE CIRCLE

***ShareScope New Subscriber Special Offer***
Readers of my blog can claim one month of free data. Click here for details.

12 October 2024
By Maynard Paton

Mark Leonard has been described as the “best capital allocator you have never heard of“.

According to Forbes, Mr Leonard is now worth $5 billion after he established Constellation Software during 1995 and listed the group on the Toronto Stock Exchange during 2006. He then watched his shares soar more than 200-fold:

(Source: SharePad)

You may not have heard of Mr Leonard because he deliberately maintains an extremely low profile. He appears to have conducted only one public interview while pictures of him online are essentially variations of this particular image:

However, Constellation’s super stock price — currently supporting a £50 billion market cap — has gradually increased the number of investors who have heard of Mr Leonard…

…and the number of investors who have tried to replicate Constellation’s success. By 2018 Mr Leonard had seen enough copycats and decided to give up writing his annual Constellation letter. He lamented:

“For competitive reasons we are limiting the information that we disclose about our acquisition activity. We believe that sharing our tactics and best practices with a host of Constellation emulators is not in our best interest.”

Such has been the enthusiasm for how Mr Leonard created his immense wealth, a Constellation ’emulator’ has even emerged within the lower reaches of AIM.

Software Circle sports an £85 million market cap and is attempting its very own Constellation-like mega-bagger journey.

Let’s take a closer look.

Read my full SOFTWARE CIRCLE article for SharePad >>

Maynard Paton

Q3 2024: Running Multi-Baggers To 40% (Or More!) Of Your Portfolio

03 October 2024
By Maynard Paton

Happy Thursday! I trust your shares have been keeping up with this year’s rising FTSE.

A summary of my portfolio’s progress:

  • Q3 return: +7.9%*
  • Q3 trades: None.
  • YTD return: +29.4%*
  • YTD winners/losers: 3 winners vs. 7 losers.

(*Performance calculated using quoted bid prices and includes all dealing costs, withholding taxes, broker-account fees, paid dividends and cash interest)

Famous last words, but my portfolio seems on course for its best annual performance since I commenced this blog at the beginning of 2015.

As I predicted within my 2023 review, System1 has dominated my returns and what was a very large weighting has become even larger. July’s positive results from the ad-testing specialist helped push my portfolio to a record high and the question now is how far do I run this winner?

Away from System1, my portfolio’s Q3 newsflow was not perfect and some profit setbacks have started to influence my dividends.

In particular, Mincon published a terrible H1 that could not even confess its payout had been paused. As I noted in my last write-up, I can only hope the group’s family directors quickly take decisive action to revive the drill manufacturer now their €2.5m annual dividend income has ceased.

Elsewhere, S & U has admitted to further bad loans following new FCA ‘forbearance’ rules. I suspect the lender’s 17% final-dividend cut earlier this year will be followed by a similar reduction within its forthcoming H1.

Other shares not improving my income during 2024 are Andrews Sykes and City of London Investment, both of which held their latest payouts following unchanged earnings. I have also enjoyed 5%-or-less dividend increases from Mountview Estates, FW Thorpe and M Winkworth.

Only Bioventix (+10%), Tristel (+100%) and System1 (payout reintroduced) have supplied very positive dividend news during the first nine months of the year. My end-of-year returns could therefore reveal a disappointing total income.

Read more

TRISTEL: New Chief Exec’s Financial Targets Keenly Awaited After Record H1 2024 Announces 30% UK Growth, 100% Dividend Jump, Bumper 84% Gross Margin And ‘$100m Opportunity’ In North America

01 October 2024
By Maynard Paton

H1 2024 results summary for Tristel (TSTL):

  • A record H1, displaying revenue up 20%, profit up 28% and the dividend up 100% underpinned by remarkable 30% UK growth and notable price increases accepted by the NHS.
  • North America is now deemed a “$100m per annum opportunity” for TSTL’s initial FDA-approved foam, although competition now involves an FDA-approved UV-light machine that may strengthen the wider argument for automated disinfections. 
  • The new chief exec ticks a lot of boxes for marketing healthcare products in the US, but his stint at LiDCO was unspectacular and shareholders keenly await his strategic ambitions, financial targets and details of his LTIP package.
  • Although employee productivity has flat-lined, the financials remain in good shape with a bumper 84% gross margin and net cash approaching £12m that could lead to another special dividend.
  • A near-term 32x P/E is not an obvious bargain, but a premium rating could be justified by further meaningful growth within established markets, the prospect of lucrative US royalties, the ongoing ability to raise prices and the possibility of successful R&D. I continue to hold.

Read more

[SharePad] Screening For My Next Long-Term Winner: CASTINGS

***ShareScope New Subscriber Special Offer***
Readers of my blog can claim one month of free data. Click here for details.

19 September 2024
By Maynard Paton

I always love a traditional ‘value bargain’. Hence this revisit to an old screen that pinpoints companies trading at less than book value.

Importantly, this screen attempts to avoid ‘value traps’ by demanding the shares carry net cash, pay a dividend and offer a history of trading above book value.

The exact filter criteria I redeployed were:

  • A price to net tangible assets of no more than 1;
  • A dividend being paid during the most recent year;
  • A 10-year average price to net tangible assets of at least 1;
  • Net borrowings less total leases of no more than 0 (i.e. a net cash position excluding IFRS 16 lease obligations), and;
  • A share price denominated in pounds sterling.

SharePad returned 10 companies, and I selected Castings because I used to own the shares and was surprised to discover the company was on the list:

(Source: SharePad)

Sure enough, Castings’ 303p shares trade (just) below the group’s 308p per share net asset value:

(Source: SharePad)

My filter results indicated the shares have traded at an average of 1.3x book value during the last ten years, while the SharePad chart above shows the rating stretching to 2x during 2014.

But there has been the odd occasion (such as now!) when the share price has fallen below book value.

Castings’ book value has advanced over time, and so has the dividend. The payout has in fact not been cut for at least 30 years:

(Source: SharePad)

Special payments were also declared for 2016, 2019, 2022, 2023 and 2024.

Given the illustrious dividend history, Castings does not seem the type of business that should be selling just below book value. Yet the shares have moved sideways for years; the 303p price was first achieved in 2007 and today supports a £132m market cap.

Let’s take a closer look.

Read my full CASTINGS article for SharePad >>

Maynard Paton

S & U: FY 2024 Confirms 41% H2 Profit Slump And 17% Final-Dividend Cut After Enhanced ‘Forbearance’ Regulations Prompt 74% Impairment Surge And Collections To Slide To A Pandemic-Like 69% 

19 September 2024
By Maynard Paton

FY 2024 results summary for S & U (SUS):

  • A very disappointing FY, with H2 profit slumping 41% and the final dividend cut by 17% as enhanced FCA “forbearance” regulations prompted the “temporary” modification of motor-finance collections and led to impairments surging 74%.
  • Various motor-finance ratios unsurprisingly deteriorated, including the first-payment proportion plunging to an alarming 94%, collections of due falling to a below-budget 90%, anticipated repayments hitting a fresh 127% low and up-to-date accounts sliding to 74%. 
  • At least the property-loan subsidiary continues to perform well, as minimal bad loans led to a new £5m profit high, an impressive 58% divisional return on equity and a company-blog ambition to double cumulative lending to £1 billion “in the next couple of years“.
  • Debt advancing to £224m and borrowing rates climbing to 8% caused net finance costs to absorb a significant 13% of revenue; extra post-FY debt could meanwhile take net finance costs from £15m to £19m and exacerbate the profit “headwinds“.
  • Post-FY references to “vigorous” FCA discussions, political intervention and up-to-date accounts running at a pandemic-like 69% now leave the £18 shares firmly below NAV, a valuation witnessed only very occasionally during the last 30 years. I continue to hold.

Read more

FW THORPE: 25% Dutch Profit Growth Supports Subdued H1 2024 As New Combined CEO/FD Role Plus Slimmed-Down Board Raise Concerns About Executive Power, Technical Expertise And Aggressive M&A

30 August 2024
By Maynard Paton

H1 2024 results summary for FW Thorpe (TFW):

  • A 5% dividend advance was the highlight of this rather subdued H1, as revenue gained 1% and profit fell 2% after customers apparently finished (very) early for Christmas.
  • Divisional performances were extremely mixed, with Dutch profit up a super 25%, Thorlux’s profit sinking a disappointing 8%, Zemper’s profit still to show its full potential and Ratio’s losses becoming even larger.
  • The accounts remain in good shape, showing an acceptable 15% group margin, healthy net cash of £29m and a very welcome stock reduction, although Ratio has (probably) required extra funding and the pension scheme may one day follow suit.
  • The roles of chief executive and finance director have been combined, which alongside a slimmed-down board raises concerns about executive technical expertise, a concentration of leadership power and future M&A that may not be adequately challenged.
  • A possible 20x P/E seemingly reflects TFW’s distinguished operating history, future “synergy initiatives” and continual demand for energy-saving lighting rather than the group’s modest near-term prospects, doubts about the re-jigged board and the risk of an aggressive acquisition strategy. I continue to hold.

Read more

[SharePad] Small-Cap Spotlight Report: LINDSELL TRAIN INVESTMENT TRUST

***ShareScope New Subscriber Special Offer***
Readers of my blog can claim one month of free data. Click here for details.

16 August 2024
By Maynard Paton

Could now be the time to back Nick Train?

The buy-and-hold fund manager was for years feted for selecting blue-chip multi-baggers such as Diageo, RELX and London Stock Exchange.

But recent times have witnessed a stark change to market conditions…

…and Mr Train admitting to a “mortifying” underperformance that even necessitated a public apology.

The shares of Lindsell Train Investment Trust, an investment trust managed by Mr Train, have for example lost 60% from their 2019 peak and are now back to a level first achieved eight years ago:

(Source: SharePad)

Yet Mr Train’s supporters may now want to consider this £154 million trust as a way of profiting from his potential comeback.

Importantly, this trust owns 24% of Mr Train’s fund-management firm, which last year paid a £39 million dividend split between Mr Train, his colleagues and this trust…

…and yet this 24% stake appears valued by the stock market at less than 2x earnings.

Let’s take a closer look.

Read my full LINDSELL TRAIN INVESTMENT TRUST article for SharePad >>

Maynard Paton

ANDREWS SYKES: ‘Robust’ FY 2023 Delivers Record £23m Profit After 13% Workforce Reduction Helps Lift Group Margin To 29% High

07 August 2024
By Maynard Paton

FY 2023 results summary for Andrews Sykes (ASY):

  • A “robust” FY performance, which delivered a record £23m profit through “careful cost management” and positive sales momentum within a number of European countries.
  • UK air-conditioning revenue declined 14% to £8m following lower summer temperatures, leaving the domestic market’s progress to again be dictated by pump hire — up 2% to register a sixth consecutive FY improvement.
  • Closing the French subsidiary, curtailing Middle Eastern losses and reducing the wider workforce by 13% were among the decisive actions that helped the group margin achieve a new 29% high.
  • The very respectable accounts showcased net cash at £20m, capex requirements of just £3m, a 34% return on equity and a “fully de-risked” pension scheme.
  • A possible 13-14x P/E does not appear outrageous, with the restricted free float, weather-sensitive operations and absence of obvious economies of scale counterbalanced perhaps by bid-target potential. I continue to hold.

Read more

M WINKWORTH: Non-Exec Appointments Invite Bid-Target Speculation After Suppressed Property Market Reduces FY 2023 Profit By 25% And ‘Top 3 Contender’ Ambition Prompts 9 Branch Closures 

29 July 2024
By Maynard Paton

FY 2023 results summary for M Winkworth (WINK):

  • Only the dividend advanced higher (+6%) as a suppressed property market alongside greater costs left franchise-network income 8% lower, revenue unchanged and profit down 25%.
  • Requiring every franchisee to be a “top three contender” prompted nine branch closures but underpinned industry-leading sales, lettings and conversion statistics versus (now anonymous) rival agents.
  • Company-owned offices now include Pimlico and collectively reported a £0.48m profit, although divisional progress remains dominated by Tooting — the exit strategy for which is unclear.
  • After reporting a lower margin, adverse cash conversion and weaker employee productivity, a post-FY update heralded a stronger FY 2024 that supports a possible 12-14x P/E and near-6% yield.
  • Celebrations marking the chairman’s 50-year tenure invite bid speculation, especially following the appointment of two non-execs with M&A backgrounds and sector merger activity involving Property Franchise and Belvoir. I continue to hold.

Read more

[SharePad] Screening For My Next Long-Term Winner: RWS

***ShareScope New Subscriber Special Offer***
Readers of my blog can claim one month of free data. Click here for details.

27 July 2024
By Maynard Paton

An illustrious dividend history and a worthwhile yield have brought RWS to my attention. The language-translation group presently offers:

  • An unbroken record of dividend increases since its 2003 flotation;
  • A despondent share price that provides a 6.5% yield;
  • Forecasts for further growth, albeit tempered by significant profit adjustments and unnerving management changes, and;
  • A long-time board member with a £170 million investment who has never sold a share.

I pinpointed RWS after revisiting a SharePad filter that shortlisted companies where the last five years had shown their dividends going up but their share prices going down:

(Source: SharePad)

I selected RWS because its shares had fallen the furthest among the shortlist. I also noted the group’s forecast P/E was a modest 8x.

Not only has RWS’s dividend increased during the last five years, the payout has been lifted every year for a remarkable 19 years!

(Source: SharePad)

But the rising dividend has not stopped the shares plummeting to 189p, which supports a £696 million market cap:

(Source: SharePad)

Let’s take closer look.

Read my full RWS article for SharePad >>

Maynard Paton

ABOUT ME

Investing in shares for 25+ years. Former share tipster. ShareScope evangelist. Blogger. Webhost nerd. FIRE | Read more | Contact

PORTFOLIO

Holdings and buy prices. Latest trades. Quarterly updates. Annual returns from 2012. Purchases from 2004 | Read more

SHARESCOPE

The most comprehensive and best value all-in-one research and data service for private investors | Special blog offer

BLOG POST ALERTS

A simple link to every new blog post. No spam!

© maynardpaton.com 2024 • Disclaimer • Privacy • Contact